A Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA) over-contribution is taxed at 1% a month on the highest excess in each month, until it’s taken out. It’s undone by withdrawing the excess, then filing a TFSA Return with the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) by June 30 of the next year.
How common it is
In 2024, about 133,000 people over-contributed to a TFSA, and CRA assessed $166.2 million in tax on the excess. That’s up from 33,000 people in 2015. The figures come from CRA, reported by Investment Executive on Sep 23, 2025. On average: $166.2 million ÷ 133,000 = about $1,250 each.
How it happens
CRA lists the usual causes:
- working out room wrongly and putting in too much
- putting a withdrawal back the same year without enough room
- paying into more than one TFSA without adding up the total
A fourth comes from timing. In January, CRA’s room figure includes the new year’s limit but not last year’s deposits. Those arrive with the spring update. CRA’s own example is someone who trusted the January figure. The TFSA room guide explains the gap.
Moving money between TFSAs yourself, instead of by direct transfer, also counts as a new deposit. See More than one TFSA?
How the 1% is worked out
CRA’s rule: 1% of the highest excess in the account in each month, for every month it remains.
- A part month counts as a month. CRA’s example: $2,000 over in June, removed in September, is four months. 4 × $20 = $80. Removed later in June, it’s one month: $20.
- The highest amount in the month counts. CRA’s example: $6,000 over in August, $4,000 withdrawn in mid-September. August and September are each taxed on $6,000: 2 × $60 = $120. The last $2,000, removed in October, adds $20.
- Deliberate over-contributions may be taxed at 100% instead, as an advantage.
How it’s undone
- Withdraw the excess. CRA says to do it as soon as possible, without waiting to hear from CRA. The bank reports the withdrawal, so no call to CRA is needed (CRA).
- File a TFSA Return. That’s Form RC243 with Schedule A (RC243-SCH-A). Both are due by June 30 of the year after the excess (CRA). For an excess in 2026, that’s June 30, 2027.
- Ask for a waiver, if it was a mistake. CRA can waive or cancel all or part of the tax when it came from a reasonable error. Send a letter that explains what happened and why waiving it would be fair (CRA). CRA also looks at how far withdrawals have corrected the error.
How CRA finds out
Banks report each year’s TFSA activity by the end of February of the next year. CRA may send a notice through your CRA account or by mail in late spring. If you don’t file a TFSA Return, CRA may send a TFSA notice of assessment later in the summer (CRA). An excess can run for months before anyone hears about it.
When there are two of you
- Each of you has your own room, so each excess belongs to one person. One partner’s unused room can’t absorb the other’s excess.
- Each of you files your own TFSA Return, if you each have an excess.
- Giving money to your partner to deposit uses their room (CRA). If they have no room left, the deposit is their excess, not yours.
A worked example
Figures in this example are examples, except CRA’s 1% rate and dates.
- Sam’s room in March 2026: $4,000.
- On Mar 10, 2026, Sam puts in $7,000. Excess: $7,000 − $4,000 = $3,000.
- Sam spots it in June and withdraws $3,000 on Jun 20, 2026.
Months with an excess: March, April, May and June, which is 4 months.
- Tax each month: 1% × $3,000 = $30
- Total: 4 × $30 = $120
Sam files Form RC243 and Schedule A by June 30, 2027, and owes the $120. If Sam had withdrawn the excess on Mar 25, the tax would have been one month: $30.
More on this topic: TFSA, RRSP and FHSA room for two people.
Larch keeps TFSA room for each of you, counting every deposit after your starting figure.
Figures on this page are examples.